Thanks ep82
I guess I should have been a little bit more descriptive with my intentions before I asked the question.
I tested four methods for coating my EVA foam. In each, where applicable, the process is as follows. The temperature was 71.5F with humidity at 49%. The PVA was lightly diluted with about 5 drops of water per ounce. The PVA was allowed to dry completely before each stage. I added two additional layers of PVA to each test piece with my new method of "wet sanding" in between each coat and also on the last coat. For "wet sanding" the PVA, I simply wait for the layer to dry completely (has gone clear), then take a piece of EVA and on the top side (most flat surface), I dip in water and "sand" the glued surface. It will reconstitute just the surface, allowing me to level and perfect it. When completed properly, the surface closely resembles glass. The Spray adhesive was allowed to flash for 30 minutes before coating over it. The plasti-dip was added as a light coating from approximately 12 inches distance, for three passes.
My methods were:
Just wood glue, then plasti-dip
RESULT: This is by far the best solution. The surface was absolutely perfect.
Wood glue, then Spray Adhesive, then plasti-dip
RESULT: Minus a bit of blotching with the plasti-dip, this was a clear second.
Spray Adhesive, then wood glue, then plasti-dip
RESULT: I noticed that the spray adhesive creates micro bubbles with the PVA that I can not seem to get rid of. I even waited for 30 minutes to let it flash off before adding the PVA. This resulted in an interesting effect that would be awesome if I were going for the texture similar to something that had rusted previously. Other than that, this was not the best and will tie for third.
Spray Adhesive, then wood glue, then spray adhesive, then plasti-dip
RESULT: Pretty much the same as above, but with just a fraction less texture. Still, this one ties for third and falls far behind the number one solution.
I appreciate your input for those that have given it. I know the evils of PVA is non-bendability, but it is a weapon, so it will be my bad if I ever put it under that stress! It is so bolstered with aluminum channels that the weapon now has practically zero bend or movement, so that should help
I know the evils of plasti-dip coming in contact with hot glue, as it has a tendency to eat away at it, hence the PVA barrier (as well as the fact that the PVA allows me to level it out). I also know not to use chemicals such as bondo or resin. The only place those were applied was to the light boxes which were made of craft sticks and cardstock. All in all, this stage is the one I am most nervous about, but I figure if I am diligent enough with my testing, I should prevail and you all will have some solid information to read about. I also think it may have been a bit unfair of me to ask the question in the first place because that puts too much potential stress on the person answering.
The test pieces are now drying for their first go-around and I will get back to you when they are done.